PDA

View Full Version : Serena on Fed Cup and her Country


tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 06:56 AM
After her second round at the French Open , here is an excerpt of the press interview :

Q. And your thinking on Fed Cup? Is that a matter of scheduling? Do you feel that you have any responsibility to the country in terms of getting into the championships? What are your thoughts on that?

SERENA WILLIAMS: Well, my only responsibility is my two dogs. So I have to make sure they're okay and that I can afford to take care of them. That's the only real responsibility I have.

Unqoute:
Serena is building schools in Africa and shows her love for that area every time, but she does not seem to have the same feelings for her own country.

Even though she gets booed at US Open / Indian Wells, it is still going overboard to be saying something like the above.


Your thoughts..

jrod
05-28-2010, 07:09 AM
I do not believe Serena's charitable interests in Africa are strictly altruistic. In fact, I think I've heard far more about her in this regard than I've heard about the charitable efforts of Bill Gates and Andre Agassi combined. Don't get me wrong as I think its great she is willing to do something to help others, but the self-serving nature in which she goes about it is rather distasteful, to say the least.

Scientist
05-28-2010, 08:00 AM
That quote is one of the dumbest, most inane things I have ever heard. And she plays it off as if she's being witty and smart, which she's not.

volleynets
05-28-2010, 08:02 AM
^ Very true. I feel like she thinks shes smarter than everybody but she's really one of the most pathetic attitudes on tour.

norbac
05-28-2010, 08:21 AM
She's so witty and funny.....

boredone3456
05-28-2010, 08:53 AM
If they offered points for Fed Cup maybe she would play a little more often.

Chadwixx
05-28-2010, 08:55 AM
Stuff like this is probably why her boyfriend dumped her.

Chadwixx
05-28-2010, 08:56 AM
If they offered doughnuts for Fed Cup maybe she would play a little more often.

Fixed it for you :)

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 09:20 AM
Inspite of such behavior, the american commentators / fed cup coach like Mary Joe would continue to heap praises on Serena or like Pam Shriver keep complaining about WTA on the HUGE 80 K fine on Serena for threatening lineswoman.

Shame on them for not standing up.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 09:26 AM
These comments are not good and make Serena look extremely petulant.

But to the point of the OP: didn't Connors have a similar attitude about Davis Cup for the majority of his career? People are acting as if Serena's the first athlete to put individual goals first.

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 10:00 AM
These comments are not good and make Serena look extremely petulant.

But to the point of the OP: didn't Connors have a similar attitude about Davis Cup for the majority of his career? People are acting as if Serena's the first athlete to put individual goals first.

Not playing for country is at one level, which several athletes do; But stating that taking care of dogs as more important than playing for country is at an other level and i hope the press comes after her.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 10:18 AM
Not playing for country is at one level, which several athletes do; But stating that taking care of dogs as more important than playing for country is at an other level and i hope the press comes after her.

I think that was more of a thing aimed at the people who think that athletes, particularly in individual sports like tennis in golf, are obliged to play for their country, that it's their 'duty' or 'responsibility'. That's where the responsibility thing comes from. Obviously she didn't convey that well at all.

BTW here's the FULL quote without the usual snipping people on here tend to do.

Q. And your thinking on Fed Cup? Is that a matter of scheduling? Do you feel that you have any responsibility to the country in terms of getting into the championships? What are your thoughts on that?

SERENA WILLIAMS: Well, my only responsibility is my two dogs. So I have to make sure they're okay and that I can afford to take care of them. That's the only real responsibility I have.
Obviously I want to do well and want Fed Cup to win. Schedule didn't work out for me. I took like, I don't know, eight, ten weeks off. It was impossible for me to play in February, or the other one, so hopefully I'll be healthy.
It's all about health and me being healthy.

http://www.rolandgarros.com/en_FR/news/interviews/2010-05-28/201005281275051082190.html

fedfan08
05-28-2010, 10:18 AM
Never did like Serena. But I'm sure the next important Fed Cup tie Mary Jo will come gravelling to Venus and Serena to play.

sureshs
05-28-2010, 10:38 AM
Serena has done more for her country through the McDonald's charity tours and her stimulation of the economy than the so-called patriots on this board, who dislike her for obvious reasons. These guys need to lift themselves up from their 2.5 tennis level and take a look at people who actually achieve something.

sureshs
05-28-2010, 10:39 AM
I do not believe Serena's charitable interests in Africa are strictly altruistic. In fact, I think I've heard far more about her in this regard than I've heard about the charitable efforts of Bill Gates and Andre Agassi combined. Don't get me wrong as I think its great she is willing to do something to help others, but the self-serving nature in which she goes about it is rather distasteful, to say the least.

Yeah Bill Gates charitable efforts has nothing to do with ensuring governments don't promote free Linux but pay for Windows machines.

Scientist
05-28-2010, 11:01 AM
^You're not brilliant, sorry.

jrod
05-28-2010, 11:16 AM
Yeah Bill Gates charitable efforts has nothing to do with ensuring governments don't promote free Linux but pay for Windows machines.


Huh? You really don't have a clue do you?

cucio
05-28-2010, 11:17 AM
Serena shouldn't think of starting up a career in stand-up comedy, that's for sure. On her discharge, I guess she must be tired sick of questions like this. No biggie, I guess. :shrugs:

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 11:20 AM
Take away the dog comments, and it's no different from what Fed has often said about Davis Cup.

West Coast Ace
05-28-2010, 11:21 AM
SERENA WILLIAMS: Well, my only responsibility is my two dogs. So I have to make sure they're okay and that I can afford to take care of them.Just proves that it's never been about the sport, it's about the $$$$. Richard Williams even said so - he was watching TV when the girls were very young and saw a girl get a check for $14k for winning a tournament - Richard was out getting tennis gear the next day.

...but the self-serving nature in which she goes about it is rather distasteful, to say the least.She has plenty of other celebrity company in this regard. I'm sure some just donate a nice chunk of money anonymously - but most want the pub.

And she plays it off as if she's being witty and smart, which she's not.Typical youngest child.

Inspite of such behavior, the american commentators / fed cup coach like Mary Joe would continue to heap praises on Serena or like Pam Shriver keep complaining about WTA on the HUGE 80 K fine on Serena for threatening lineswoman.
Someone very smart said something about a new sucker being born all the time...

sureshs
05-28-2010, 11:24 AM
There are so many US players in the top 10 other than the Williams sisters that I don't understand why any Fed Cup captain would ask them to play. I would pick high-ranked players like Jill Craybas and Vania King any day.

jrod
05-28-2010, 11:26 AM
....
She has plenty of other celebrity company in this regard. I'm sure some just donate a nice chunk of money anonymously - but most want the pub.

...

Right. In all fairness to her and the others, the more publicity they get the better the charity does. It's a win-win and that's the way it's designed. I just find the spin Serena's handlers put on her efforts nauseating.

sureshs
05-28-2010, 11:26 AM
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/11/13/gates_gives_100m_to_fight/


Gates gives $100m to fight HIV, $421m to fight Linux
Alert Print News from India and some letters

By Thomas C Greene in Washington DC • Get more from this author

Posted in Software, 13th November 2002 04:23 GMT

We do hate to rain on a high-profile corporate love-fest, but we have to point out that in addition to the much trumpeted $100 million Billg has donated to India's fight against HIV, he's funding the Microsoft jihad against Linux to the far more impressive tune of $421 million. That means that Linux is more than four times worse than AIDS to Billg and his happy Redmond family. God forbid any of them should learn the bitter truth the hard way and start talking sense.

Billg's personal $100 million goes to health initiatives over ten years, while $421 million of Microsoft's money goes, over a mere three years, to support MS-friendly development and 'educational' initiatives. And being a monster MS shareholder himself, a 'Big Win' in India will enrich him personally, perhaps well in excess of the $100 million he's donating to the AIDS problem. Makes you wonder who the real beneficiary of charity is here.

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 11:37 AM
Philanthropy and Altruism depends on each individual and even if Serena does not spend a penny for her country it is understandable.

But being a top sports athlete and her country's ambassador for the whole decade, making such statements is ludicrous and is not in thr true spirit of a sportsman even in the case of an individual sport.

She thinks she is classy, but her acts over the last couple of years is taking her down in terms of public image. She is getting publicity , but i doubt whether it is of the good kind.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 11:46 AM
Philanthropy and Altruism depends on each individual and even if Serena does not spend a penny for her country it is understandable.

But being a top sports athlete and her country's ambassador for the whole decade, making such statements is ludicrous and is not in thr true spirit of a sportsman even in the case of an individual sport.

She thinks she is classy, but her acts over the last couple of years is taking her down in terms of public image. She is getting publicity , but i doubt whether it is of the good kind.

She's already won Fed Cup 3 times and has played it since 1999.

Like I said, compare her comments to those of Federer on Davis Cup and you'll see very little difference.

jerriy
05-28-2010, 11:49 AM
Do you feel that you have any responsibility to the country in terms of getting into the championships?SERENA WILLIAMS: Well, my only responsibility is my two dogs.LMAO :mrgreen:

onyxrose81
05-28-2010, 11:55 AM
If I was Mary Jo, I would just leave the WS alone. It's beyond obvious now that they don't care about FC anymore so enough is enough. Maybe the other American women can play and learn how to win **** occasionally.

West Coast Ace
05-28-2010, 11:56 AM
Like I said, compare her comments to those of Federer on Davis Cup and you'll see very little difference.Those who rag on Fed are way off. The Swiss have no men's depth - the weight of the country is on his back to win every match, every round. The US women can win a round without Venus and Serena.

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 12:12 PM
She's already won Fed Cup 3 times and has played it since 1999.

Like I said, compare her comments to those of Federer on Davis Cup and you'll see very little difference.

Can you please quote which statement of Federer compares that to Serena in this context ? Federer and Nadal are totally different class. Please do not denigrate them comparing to Serena.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 12:21 PM
Can you please quote which statement of Federer compares that to Serena in this context ? Federer and Nadal are totally different class. Please do not denigrate them comparing to Serena.

Take out the dog comment and read the rest of the quote (which you tastefully left out BTW) and it's not too different from what other players, including Nadal and Fed, have said about DC and putting health first. But of course Serena gets no benefit of the doubt on here, so that's to be expected.

sureshs
05-28-2010, 12:21 PM
Nadal should win all 4 Slams before he can even be considered to be in Serena's league.

Chadwixx
05-28-2010, 12:23 PM
Take out the dog comment and read the rest of the quote (which you tastefully left out BTW) and it's not too different from what other players, including Nadal and Fed, have said about DC and putting health first. But of course Serena gets no benefit of the doubt on here, so that's to be expected.

Sticking up for your favorite player and comparing her to fed again :oops: :D

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 12:25 PM
Nadal should win all 4 Slams before he can even be considered to be in Serena's league.

Arent there 5 of them ? So, which slam are you excluding ? :)

sureshs
05-28-2010, 12:26 PM
Those who rag on Fed are way off. The Swiss have no men's depth - the weight of the country is on his back to win every match, every round. The US women can win a round without Venus and Serena.

Stan plays a decent game. And his backhand is better than Federer's.

tennisaddict
05-28-2010, 12:29 PM
Take out the dog comment and read the rest of the quote (which you tastefully left out BTW) and it's not too different from what other players, including Nadal and Fed, have said about DC and putting health first. But of course Serena gets no benefit of the doubt on here, so that's to be expected.

The whole issue is with the 'dog comment' . So removing that does not make any sense. The rest of the quote is an after thought of Serena (do a google search). If Serena had just talked about her health, there would not be an issue, since we know what her take is on Fed Cup.

jerriy
05-28-2010, 12:31 PM
These comments are not good and make Serena look extremely petulant.

But to the point of the OP: didn't Connors have a similar attitude about Davis Cup for the majority of his career? People are acting as if Serena's the first athlete to put individual goals first.Connors did it for commercial reasons, not cuz he wanted more time to prepare for grand slam tournaments. Anyway so what if Connors did it? You're acting as if he was complimented for his action. In fact Connors' peculiar individualism led him to being kicked out of tournaments... he even ended up getting banned from a grand slam. And that was while he was at his peak.

In other words, nobody approved of Connors' attitude towards the Davis Cup, so nobody is obliged to approve Serena's.

West Coast Ace
05-28-2010, 12:35 PM
Stan plays a decent game. He's 2 and 6 in 8 ATP finals matches; he beats lower ranked players and can't be those above him - those he'd be expected to beat in a Davis Cup SF or F:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stan_Wawrinka

So you're attempt to deflect the Williams Sisters' bad behavior toward Fed is lame. Serena said it - it's all about the money.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 12:46 PM
Sticking up for your favorite player and comparing her to fed again :oops: :D

Wait so my favorite player is Serena? I guess that's obvious judging from my username and the fact that I was so happy that ESPN chose to show her match today over live tennis. :rolleyes:

Just because I don't fall in line with the majority Serena bashers on here doesn't mean I'm some uber-**********, let's get that straight right now.

West Coast Ace
05-28-2010, 12:49 PM
...doesn't mean I'm some uber-**********, But you still like her and respect her, right? No lying, James wouldn't approve.

jamesblakefan#1
05-28-2010, 12:58 PM
But you still like her and respect her, right? No lying, James wouldn't approve.

Blake and Serena are good friends. But that's irrelevant.

It's as if Serena's some evil person to some of you people. Anyone that doesn't despise her must be insane. It's pretty funny.

LDVTennis
05-28-2010, 02:40 PM
Take out the dog comment and read the rest of the quote (which you tastefully left out BTW) and it's not too different from what other players, including Nadal and Fed, have said about DC and putting health first. But of course Serena gets no benefit of the doubt on here, so that's to be expected.

Yeah, but the "dog" part of the answer makes a big difference. You just can't take it out.

She was put on the defensive and because she did not have a good explanation for her actions she became flippant. That's just so wrong.

This is not the first time Serena has acted this way. She acted the same way when reporters asked her to explain her outburst at the US Open. She was flippant. So, why should anyone give her the benefit of the doubt.

West Coast Ace
05-28-2010, 02:41 PM
Yeah, but the "dog" part of the answer makes a big difference. You just can't take it out.

She was put on the defensive and because she did not have a good explanation for her actions she became flippant. That's just so wrong.

This is not the first time Serena has acted this way. She acted the same way when reporters asked her to explain her outburst at the US Open. She was flippant. So, why should anyone give her the benefit of the doubt.Very well said. She has a reputation. These most recent comments just cement it in the minds of everyone who isn't on her bandwagon - or payroll (I'm sure her dogs approve - LOL!)

jrod
05-28-2010, 04:06 PM
....
Gates gives $100m to fight HIV, $421m to fight Linux
....

Not that I am a fan of Microsoft (in fact, I despise them), but it's just a tad disingenuous to focus on only a fraction his foundations charitable contributions. Clearly, the more successful he is with Microsoft, the more funds that will be made available to charitable efforts. In fact, it's probably the single most efficient way of directing funds to those in need. The fact of the matter is that the success of Linux will do next to nothing to help anyone truly in need.

decades
05-28-2010, 04:24 PM
Serena plays for the Money. Not her Country. Put that in your pipe and smoke it J P McEnroe.

Tanya
05-28-2010, 10:02 PM
Who cares? If she feels more responsibility toward her dogs than toward Fed Cup then what does it matter? Some of you are saying you'd rather see people like Craybas playing anyway so you should be happy about it.

The Serena-hate stopped being trendy in '09, lets get with the times people.

Also stop acting like Serena is the only athlete in the world that plays for the money. Take a nice dose of reality please.

cucio
05-29-2010, 02:38 AM
The fact of the matter is that the success of Linux will do next to nothing to help anyone truly in need.

That's immensely arguable, isn't it? At many levels:

1) Economical: money spent in software licenses can be redirected to other areas.

2) Educational: source code is a valuable tool for education in computer science.

3) Philosophical: the free software movement promotes a spirit of knowledge sharing and cooperation.

This thread sucks and is now about humanitarianism. :)

MotherMarjorie
05-29-2010, 05:26 AM
Mother Marjorie thinks Serena Williams has the right to play Fed Cup as her schedule deems. Other top US players have played Fed Cup at-will and she deserves the same consideration. Her knee has been problematic most of the year and she's just getting back into tournament form. When the time is right, she will play. The '12 Olympics isn't that far away and she'll have ample motivation to play before then.

jamesblakefan#1
08-12-2010, 01:22 PM
Venus and Serena commit to U.S. team for 2010 Fed Cup Final

http://www.usta.com/venus_and_serena_commit_to_us_team_for_2010_fed_cu p_final/

Mulligan
08-12-2010, 01:36 PM
Who cares? ........Also stop acting like Serena is the only athlete in the world that plays for the money. Take a nice dose of reality please.

Pretty much sums it up. These threads are as lame as it gets...

fantom
08-13-2010, 04:42 AM
Venus and Serena commit to U.S. team for 2010 Fed Cup Final

http://www.usta.com/venus_and_serena_commit_to_us_team_for_2010_fed_cu p_final/

Why the hell are they playing the Fed Cup Finals when they didn't play all year? Sure, they give the US the best chance at winning, but what about the players who actually committed themselves and worked to get there? Should they just take a back seat and watch the Williams sisters seal the deal for them? It just doesn't seem right to me.

On the other hand, I'm sure one or both of them will find a reason to pull out anyways....

THUNDERVOLLEY
08-13-2010, 05:02 AM
Sure, they give the US the best chance at winning

...no other observation is required, since you alreadly acknowledge the irrefutable reason why they can play on the team without committing to the degree as other American players.

MotherMarjorie
08-13-2010, 05:21 AM
Mother Marjorie read where both Venus and Serena have decided to play the Fed Cup finals against Italy! Hurray! Fran gets on Mother Majorie's last nerve.

But even if Venus and Serena chose not to play, it is their right. They have more than shouldered their fair share of Fed Cup and Olympic doubles matches.

It will be nice to see the US with their strongest team heading into the finals.

Hence On and Forth So,

Mother Marjorie Ann

MotherMarjorie
08-13-2010, 05:28 AM
Why the hell are they playing the Fed Cup Finals when they didn't play all year? Sure, they give the US the best chance at winning, but what about the players who actually committed themselves and worked to get there? Should they just take a back seat and watch the Williams sisters seal the deal for them? It just doesn't seem right to me.

On the other hand, I'm sure one or both of them will find a reason to pull out anyways....
Oh, Mother Majorie must speak out. Oh, yes she must!

1st, Serena has had injury issues most of the year and it would seem foolish to aggrevate injury, adding insult.

2nd, Its obvious the US team didn't need its best players to advance forward against weaker countries in Fed Cup and that's okay and good. However, given the opportunity to have the two best Americans playing for the Fed Cup title, how could Mary Jo let that opportunity slip by?

If Mary Jo benched Venus and Serena for the Fed Cup finals, she would not be asked to return as Captain of the US Fed Cup team. The 2012 Olympics aren't that far away either, and Mary Jo wants her best there as well.

It Hurts, But Its The Truth,

Mother Marjorie Ann

pmerk34
08-13-2010, 06:10 AM
Serena has done more for her country through the McDonald's charity tours and her stimulation of the economy than the so-called patriots on this board, who dislike her for obvious reasons. These guys need to lift themselves up from their 2.5 tennis level and take a look at people who actually achieve something.

Now we care about Fed cup? Sure. No one cares about Fed Cup so why should she?

fantom
08-13-2010, 06:57 AM
Oh, Mother Majorie must speak out. Oh, yes she must!

1st, Serena has had injury issues most of the year and it would seem foolish to aggrevate injury, adding insult.

2nd, Its obvious the US team didn't need its best players to advance forward against weaker countries in Fed Cup and that's okay and good. However, given the opportunity to have the two best Americans playing for the Fed Cup title, how could Mary Jo let that opportunity slip by?

If Mary Jo benched Venus and Serena for the Fed Cup finals, she would not be asked to return as Captain of the US Fed Cup team. The 2012 Olympics aren't that far away either, and Mary Jo wants her best there as well.

It Hurts, But Its The Truth,

Mother Marjorie Ann

I totally understand from the coaches point of view. I don't think the Williams sisters should throw their names into consideration at this point in the season. Both Roddick and Agassi have said in the past that they wouldn't feel comfortable swooping in at the end of the season if the team got to the final rounds. It's just showing respect for the players who made the commitment.

"Jimmie likes Elaine"

Federerx16
08-13-2010, 07:41 AM
Yay! Now the US will actually win matches this time. :o

jamesblakefan#1
08-13-2010, 09:54 AM
I totally understand from the coaches point of view. I don't think the Williams sisters should throw their names into consideration at this point in the season. Both Roddick and Agassi have said in the past that they wouldn't feel comfortable swooping in at the end of the season if the team got to the final rounds. It's just showing respect for the players who made the commitment.

"Jimmie likes Elaine"

Well in that case it's damned if you do and damned if you don't. People would complain if they didn't play, as we saw earlier in this thread, and now that they commit to playing (for now) people still complain. It really is like they can do no right in certain people's eyes.

You really think Oudin and King or whoever else the US has gives them a better shot at winning?

Mulligan
08-13-2010, 10:26 AM
Well in that case it's damned if you do and damned if you don't. People would complain if they didn't play, as we saw earlier in this thread, and now that they commit to playing (for now) people still complain. It really is like they can do no right in certain people's eyes.

You really think Oudin and King or whoever else the US has gives them a better shot at winning?

Don't be so logical. People's heads will start to explode around here.

elroyjet
08-13-2010, 10:44 AM
let's see if they still play. just b/c they commit doesn't mean they play...

Sidd Finch
08-13-2010, 12:01 PM
let's see if they still play. just b/c they commit doesn't mean they play...

...as is the case with most players in men's/women's tour.

I hope they play, it would be good tennis.

TMF
08-13-2010, 12:27 PM
Who cares? If she feels more responsibility toward her dogs than toward Fed Cup then what does it matter? Some of you are saying you'd rather see people like Craybas playing anyway so you should be happy about it.

The Serena-hate stopped being trendy in '09, lets get with the times people.

Also stop acting like Serena is the only athlete in the world that plays for the money. Take a nice dose of reality please.

The dog comment was immature. She’s better off saying nothing, or add “no comment” which could have save her face. She’s selfish and everyone knows that. Everything she does always raises a question..."what's in it for me". If nothing, forget it, she rather go shopping with her dogs !

THUNDERVOLLEY
08-13-2010, 01:23 PM
Who cares?

Creatures consumed by hatred.


Also stop acting like Serena is the only athlete in the world that plays for the money. Take a nice dose of reality please.

True, but when hatred drives the minds of certain TTW members, facts such as many players only entering pro sports for money...or taking huge endorsement deals...or taking fat paydays for media appearances all seem to vanish, as any acknowledgement of others' said facts instantly means Serena is not the phantom villain of their limp, sad fantasties.

TMF
08-13-2010, 02:32 PM
Creatures consumed by hatred.




True, but when hatred drives the minds of certain TTW members, facts such as many players only entering pro sports for money...or taking huge endorsement deals...or taking fat paydays for media appearances all seem to vanish, as any acknowledgement of others' said facts instantly means Serena is not the phantom villain of their limp, sad fantasties.

Did you read the post from the OP? When was the last time an American player makes dumb excuse by saying her pet is the reason why she’s not playing? She act as if her children is sick and she needs to take care of them. LOL. Fact is she doesn’t want to play and you chose a poor excuse to make one. I never heard a player make poorer excuse than Serena, not even Nadal with his injuries. Maybe Serena should hire someone to speak for her, b/c whenever she open her mouth, it always turned out ugly !

jamesblakefan#1
08-13-2010, 02:40 PM
Did you read the post from the OP? When was the last time an American player makes dumb excuse by saying her pet is the reason why she’s not playing? She act as if her children is sick and she needs to take care of them. LOL. Fact is she doesn’t want to play and you chose a poor excuse to make one. I never heard a player make poorer excuse than Serena, not even Nadal with his injuries. Maybe Serena should hire someone to speak for her, b/c whenever she open her mouth, it always turned out ugly !

TMF once again not passing up on the opportunity to rip on Serena.

Read the full quote:

SERENA WILLIAMS: Well, my only responsibility is my two dogs. So I have to make sure they're okay and that I can afford to take care of them. That's the only real responsibility I have.
Obviously I want to do well and want Fed Cup to win. Schedule didn't work out for me. I took like, I don't know, eight, ten weeks off. It was impossible for me to play in February, or the other one, so hopefully I'll be healthy.
It's all about health and me being healthy.

The 'responsibility' thing was obviously a jab at those who feel like Serena is required to play Fed Cup, despite the fact that other players (your idol, for example) aren't held to the same standards.

TMF
08-13-2010, 02:47 PM
The 'responsibility' thing was obviously a jab at those who feel like Serena is required to play Fed Cup, despite the fact that other players (your idol, for example) aren't held to the same standards.

Someone had posted about Fed playing more DC than Nadal, more than Sampras. Yet, he still get rip apart, and discredit him for not winning DC while ignoring the fact that it required an overall STRONG team to win.

fantom
08-13-2010, 03:09 PM
Well in that case it's damned if you do and damned if you don't. People would complain if they didn't play, as we saw earlier in this thread, and now that they commit to playing (for now) people still complain. It really is like they can do no right in certain people's eyes.

You really think Oudin and King or whoever else the US has gives them a better shot at winning?

I would have no problem if they decided not to play Fed Cup. They aren't exactly young anymore and if the schedule doesn't work for them then they have the right to not play. If they were injured, they could have still made the commitment to play on the team if they were healthy. I don't like the way they decided to wait until the finals to show up.

By the way, I don't like Serena much but I've always supported Venus.

jamesblakefan#1
08-13-2010, 03:11 PM
Someone had posted about Fed playing more DC than Nadal, more than Sampras. Yet, he still get rip apart, and discredit him for not winning DC while ignoring the fact that it required an overall STRONG team to win.

Serena skips Fed Cup because she feels the same way about it as Fed does about Davis Cup - if it fits into her schedule then fine, but her health and preparing for the majors is what is most important. Fed stated as much earlier this year when he skipped the tie vs Spain. When Serena does it she's being selfish. Federer does it and he's being smart. Gotta love hypocrisy.