Just curious, who would you put ahead of Federer based on accomplishments on clay? Do you put Kuerten ahead of him? What about Tilden who won a million clay tournaments? What about Nadal or Borg? Rosewall won a number of French Titles plus French Pros and many other clay tournaments. Does Laver who also won a number of French titles, Italian Championships plus many other clay titles belong? Vilas won the French Open and the US Open on clay. Cochet won many French titles. Rene Lacoste, that fine maker of tennis clothing won three French titles. Lendl, that wonderful golfer and Wilander won many clay titles and several French Opens. Wilding won a million clay titles including the World Hardcourt which was the clay court World Championship before the French. If we look at accomplishments alone where does Federer belong? Federer's a fantastic clay court player but tennis does have a long history with a lot of great clay court players. Certainly Federer has the ability to beat anyone on the list. If you want I can list the accomplishments of many of these players on clay and put them next to Federer's on clay and you can decide objectively.