1. Murray game was better before Gilbert. He seems to be slipping. 2. Roddick will not get any better no matter who is coaching, Connors can’t perform miracles. 3. Federer would be much better off without Roach. Roach started the demise of Lendl a few years back, and now Federer is on a down hill path. Murray and Federer have tremendous natural ability, why not just let it develop, they already have the court smarts to make things happen.