How does one rate Roddick vs Murray now. Both have a slam. Both have 5 slam finals. Roddick has a year end #1. Murray has more Masters and an Olympic Gold. Neither have WTF. I think it is pretty close and mostly subjective in alot of ways. Murray owns Roddick though and won most of their matches even as an upstart ranked outside the top 20. That might be the tiebreaker in his favor.