Tennis Ball Machine vs wall?

mctoasted1

New User
Im 15 years old & have a proper coach, who trains me once a week & I play comp aswell. I really need more time practising, however noone is keen to play. Should i invest in a ball machine or simply hit against a wall. I've got a coach who is able to run me through techniques, footwork etc etc & I'm grasping a lot from it & i've gotten noticeably better, however I neeeed more hitting time, Im eager to progress.
So, based on my scenario, should I get a tennis ball machine or simply hit against a wall?

Thank you
 

Lazarus

Rookie
I would always say wall.

IMHO nothing precedes wall when it comes down to practicing and improving your techniques. I have spent countless hours on wall practicing so I do know what am I talking about.
 

COPEY

Hall of Fame
I also grew up hitting against a wall, and it is indeed a very good way to improve specific aspects of your game...however, a ball machine trumps a wall every time. Given all the things you can work on with a wall, a ball machine affords you even more versatility. Right now I have a few of the high school kids I teach working on their transition game. I set the machine to deliver a low ball with underspin, the kids will move forward, execute a half-carioca step, chip or slice the ball, at which point I kill the ball machine. If the ball lands in, I hit it back toward them--not with the intent to pass them per se, but rather to force them to hit a volley. As I'm striking the ball, they perform a split step, then execute the volley. Next student, repeat.

I've done that drill where the machine will feed the next ball to force a volley as well, but even though I'm using a slight variation, it's an example of something you simply can't duplicate on a wall. I can also set my machine up to simulate overheads - very high overheads (using a block to elevate the front of the machine), then set the 2-line function to random, forcing the kids to move from point to point as they hit overheads.

Again, you can certainly practice your slices, volleys, certain aspects of your footwork - quite a few different things on the wall, but the fact remains that everything you can do on a wall you can do with a machine, and a lot more.

That said, do you "need" a ball machine to improve? Absolutely not. In my prime I was a solid 5.0, and I never used a machine. I still don't now actually; I primarily use mine to teach with. But if you can afford one and you're serious about improving, it's a nice luxury to have.

One last thing - nothing takes the place of actual match play, hitting live balls; learning to read the shot, working on court positioning, anticipation, timing, spacing, etc. when hitting against a human being can't be duplicated with a machine or wall. A machine, like a wall is merely a training tool that allows you to hone specific skills. Live ball play affords you the opportunity to work on incorporating those skills into matchplay. ;-)
 
Last edited:

sundaypunch

Hall of Fame
Nothing wrong with the wall, but a ball machine is great if you can afford it. You can do many things with a ball machine that just aren't practical on a wall.

My overheads and volleys have improved considerably because of hitting hundreds and hundreds of them on the ball machine. It is also great for practicing high bouncing shots to the backhand, etc.
 

ramos77

Semi-Pro
why don't you sign up with tennisbook.com.au or sportsmatchmaker.com.au

You should easily be able to find a hitting partner, find someone that's a bit better than you...

a tennis ball machine is better than a wall IMO (you don't know where the ball will land against a wall), but you don't need one to be a good player. if you need to work on a stroke, then tell your coach to help you with it...
 

bugeyed

Semi-Pro
One big advantage with a ball machine is that you can see if your ball is staying in & work on that. At best, the wall shows the clearance over the net, but nothing else.

Cheers,
kev
 

dak95_00

Hall of Fame
One big advantage with a ball machine is that you can see if your ball is staying in & work on that. At best, the wall shows the clearance over the net, but nothing else.

I grew up hitting against a wall and still do when I don't want to get my ball mahine out but the above poster said it all. Against a wall, you can slam shots all day and they come back. Against a machine, a new ball comes back but you got to see where the old ball landed; big, Big, BIG advantage!
 
Top