Talk Tennis

Talk Tennis (http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/index.php)
-   Stringing Techniques / Stringing Machines (http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/forumdisplay.php?f=23)
-   -   GSS vs. Gamma Starting Clamp (http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/showthread.php?t=389956)

Donny0627 07-22-2011 10:26 AM

GSS vs. Gamma Starting Clamp
 
Just opened my mailbox and found that my GSS starting clamp came in. I have had the Gamma clamp for around 6 months, and have been unimpressed by its quality and holding strength. My first impressions were that the GSS is much harder to open, despite it having one less spring. Also, there is no inserted diamond-coated punchout in the GSS one, the clamp face itself is textured.

The shipping was fast and cheap. I thought it was funny when the owner called me personally to thank me for my order, but I didnt mind. All in all I would definitely suggest the GSS clamp over the Gamma so far, and will try to finish the review the next time I string a racket.

Irvin 07-22-2011 11:20 AM

I have a Gamma starting clamp and one of the old Babolat starting clamps that is supposed to be so great. I will admit my Babolat is much harder to open and it has two spring where the Gamma has three. BUT, the Gamma has never slipped for me. How good is good enough. I will say this though I NEVER pull tension against a clamp with no tension on the other side of the clamp no matter what type clamp I am using.

Irvin

kchau 07-22-2011 11:26 AM

I've never had issues with my gamma clamp. even at tensions up to 65lb

GlenK 07-22-2011 11:27 AM

I have a Gamma and one from GSS too. Both have been excellent!!

Donny0627 07-22-2011 12:34 PM

the gamma tends to collect residue from the string, and does not come clean even after a thorough scrubbing with alchohol... at least for me. It has slipped several times for me, often costing me a stringjob.

diredesire 07-22-2011 12:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Irvin (Post 5852963)
I have a Gamma starting clamp and one of the old Babolat starting clamps that is supposed to be so great. I will admit my Babolat is much harder to open and it has two spring where the Gamma has three. BUT, the Gamma has never slipped for me. How good is good enough. I will say this though I NEVER pull tension against a clamp with no tension on the other side of the clamp no matter what type clamp I am using.

Irvin

Maybe the Gamma has improved, but I have a similar experience to OP. I've also had the chance to work with a Gamma Starter in the past year, and it was similar. The Gamma's diamond dusted coating is too smooth, and the plates have a potential for not being aligned correctly/they will eventually fall out.

I'm not positive on your mains starting method, but I use my starter as a backup to the initial pull.

mad dog1 07-22-2011 12:44 PM

my experience w/ gamma starting clamp is similar to OP and DD. i use my clamp as a bridge and it wouldn't hold. i have used the eagnas and babolat as a bridge the same way and they both held no prob altho the babolat did slip once but it was dirty. once i cleaned it, it was good to go again. i also use my starting clamp to tighten knots. i grab the clamp head when i pull and have had the gamma starter release on me. the eagnas has not released on me ever.

jim e 07-22-2011 06:27 PM

I have an alpha, a gamma, and the gss clamp, and I prefer the gss clamp the most. The alpha clamp is larger plate size, and like you said the gss clamp has stiffer springs, so it holds remarkably well.I keep the alpha with a string in place all the time for its use as a bridge when needed, and the gss clamp for all other uses. The gss is very well made.
Just a note, be sure and keep your starting clamp clean as well as your machines clamps, as after a period of time, I was just cleaning the machines clamps, and not the starting clamps and a set of VS gut slipped through the starter when starting crosses (I now use a different method of starting crosses) .It ended up because of dirty starting clamp, so do not ignore cleaning the starting clamp as well when you clean the machines clamps.

mchjhn 07-24-2011 12:01 PM

try using a tooth brush dipped in rubbing alcohol to clean your starting clamp and string clamps. sometimes, if you use a clothe, the fibers will wear off inside the diamond coated surface, and make it the gripping worse. a tooth brush will get the "string slime" out of the diamond coating. works great for me.

jim e 07-24-2011 12:26 PM

A white shoelace dipoped in alcohol works nice as well. You can pull the lace through easing up on the clamp, and that works real nice.

diredesire 07-25-2011 08:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jim e (Post 5853734)
I have an alpha, a gamma, and the gss clamp, and I prefer the gss clamp the most. The alpha clamp is larger plate size, and like you said the gss clamp has stiffer springs, so it holds remarkably well.I keep the alpha with a string in place all the time for its use as a bridge when needed, and the gss clamp for all other uses. The gss is very well made.
Just a note, be sure and keep your starting clamp clean as well as your machines clamps, as after a period of time, I was just cleaning the machines clamps, and not the starting clamps and a set of VS gut slipped through the starter when starting crosses (I now use a different method of starting crosses) .It ended up because of dirty starting clamp, so do not ignore cleaning the starting clamp as well when you clean the machines clamps.

Just a historical note: The "Alpha" clamp that was sold on TW waaaay back was actually an Alpha/RAB clamp, which is the same as the current GSS clamp. The newer Alpha clamp that TW sold a little while back is the current, wider jawed starter with the alpha logo. I also like the GSS/RAB clamp the best. The Alpha is extremely aggressive with extreme holding power. It's a great clamp, but a little overkill and bulky. I'd trust it in excess of 90lbs, but it also can squish strings a little bit.

Donny0627 07-27-2011 04:14 PM

just a follow up on my OP. Used the GSS clamp the other day, worked flawlessly. I actually had one of my flying clamps break on me, good thing I have 2 starting clamps... I was able ot do a couple stringjobs with just the one, but it isnt fun lol

spillai 08-03-2011 08:24 AM

The GSS clamp is much better quality, but it is also pricier

Donny0627 08-03-2011 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spillai (Post 5876463)
The GSS clamp is much better quality, but it is also pricier

actually they're about the same price

Peppershaker 08-03-2011 06:21 PM

Had been thinking it would be nice to have two Starting Clamps. Had seen some slipping with my Gamma so based on this board decided to purchase the GSS model.

Came in the other day, used it a couple of times since.....Wow!

Roger Wawrinka 09-29-2012 09:12 PM

Just a quick question, what are your guys thoughts on the black babolat starting clamp (2 springs)?

cluckcluck 09-29-2012 09:15 PM

I've had an Eagnas starting clamp for over a year now and I've never had a problem. Easy to open and grips extremely well. Cheap too.

Irvin 09-30-2012 02:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peppershaker (Post 5877627)
Had been thinking it would be nice to have two Starting Clamps. Had seen some slipping with my Gamma so based on this board decided to purchase the GSS model.

Came in the other day, used it a couple of times since.....Wow!

I have two clamps and usually use both when I string, I've never used them back to back though. My Gamma has never slipped while stringing, but I have never pulled directly against it either except for when I made a video once.

Peppershaker 09-30-2012 02:42 PM

I do not pull directly against either clamp, but have experienced just about everything as posted on this board. Have had the Gamma slip when used as a bridge (oil/string residue), had one plate fall out, have seen that the pads gum up quickly and require cleaning more often than the GSS. I still use the Gamma, but now never as a bridge. I like it for use when tightening knots, but outside of that I'll reach for my GSS clamp.

Having had one pad fall out which I've since glued back, was glad that I had two clamps. Could probably have improvised, but have decided I'll purchase another GSS, have a feeling that one or the other pad will drop out at any time.

One other advantage to the GSS is that you can take it apart, something that I would have really liked while attempting to clean, and then re-glue the Gamma. Although just thought that I'd check this feature out on my GSS. Didn't have much luck but didn't attempt to pound too hard either.

sstchur 09-30-2012 04:02 PM

Don't know if the Gamma clamp has changed since when DD used it, but I have 2 Gamma clamps and an Eagnas clamp. The Eagnas clamp is extremely tight, almost too tight for my taste. I used to prefer it over the Gamma b/c it was obviously stronger.

But as I used them more and more I now prefer the Gamma. It's not hard to open which makes it much faster and enjoyable to use for me. It has also never slipped and I use it to start my mains and my crosses all the time (as well as to tighten knots).

I've had no issues with it collecting residue. I clean it regularly and it works very very well.

The only thing that Gamma could do better is make that diamond coating infused into the clamp instead of on a thin piece of metal that is then glued to the clamp.

Other than that though, it's a very good clamp and it works very very well.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:39 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© 2006 - Tennis Warehouse