If you end up getting a club team together (like a travelling intramural all-star team), there are a few other college club teams out that direction. Michigan and Miami's teams are at least as good as an elite D-3 team.
Michigan - firstname.lastname@example.org
Miami of Ohio - email@example.com
West Virginia - Brandyn.Fisher@mail.wvu.edu
Ohio State has a team, too, but I can't find their contact address right now.