Originally Posted by pc1
It wasn't McCauley or Geist's logic. It was the official Pro Rankings that had Rosewall as number one. It was I believe an odd ranking system but nevertheless Rosewall was the "official number one" so I think he deserves at least co-number one for the year.
I think you're right. The title of McCauley's chapter referred to the rankings, rather than his personal opinion. Otherwise it doesn't follow.