Originally Posted by Rippy
Federer has beaten Murray, Djokovic, del Potro, and Soderling on his way to slam titles.
(It's also amusing how you've only included the factors at which Nadal beats Federer)
you´re right, but, how many? I´m sure most of his GS are not against nadal, murray or Djoker (the one against Soderling does not really count since Soderling was a novice and played way worse than he was playing). If you drop federer´s slams against hewitt, safin, roddick and so on, he´d be 7-8 or so right? fair enough, those slams do count, but you´ll agree that those rivals were not so good. That´s obvious