Really depends on the serve. I play against a wide variety of style and skill level being mainly a public court pick-up player nowadays.
If I'm facing a competent server with some decent pace and placement I go with the abbreviated take back and redirect using their pace to fuel my own, usually aiming DTL or at their feet, but will go CC if their sere takes me that way.
If I'm playing a dinker or a spin it in type I usually step up and rip it going for the winner DTL or CC and accept the increased number of errors, it's just more fun.
I do play a 1HBH so against top notch servers I do block or slice the ball back off that wing, but I have actually developed a very consistent and effective FH serve return, very simple and compact.
So I guess I choose redirect since I have to pick one.
(2) iPrestige MP 370g 12ptsHL, PT280 370g 10ptsHL