Thread: Clay Court GOAT
View Single Post
Old 06-12-2012, 05:42 AM   #964
jean pierre
Semi-Pro
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 682
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by pc1 View Post
But there are also questions on how good Nadal was when he was starting to beat Federer on clay. Nadal was a teen when he was defeating Federer on red clay. My opinion is that Nadal is a superior player on clay now to his teen years. I think he has a better serve, backhand, volley and he hits harder. So how do we judge Federer's performances against Nadal in the early days when he would on occasion defeat Nadal on clay?

As far as the great clay players of all time here are some candidates in no order.
Borg
Rosewall-Rosewall won a ton of French Pros, many of them on red clay at Roland Garros. He also won the French Champions (now the French Open) as an amateur and the first French Open in 1968 over Rod Laver. And you can add a lot of other top clay tournaments that he won.
Nadal
Tilden
Kuerten
Wilander
Lendl
Laver
Lacoste
Cochet
Muster
Bruguera
von Cramm
And Vilas ? Stronger than Muster, Kuerten or Brugera !
jean pierre is offline   Reply With Quote