Originally Posted by helloworld
Mcenroe was one of the best server in his generation. Federer is not even top 5 server in his generation(Karlovic, Isner, Roddick, Johansson, Querry were better servers). I'd take McEnroe on the serve department, but not by much.
When did McEnroe face sticks and trees like Isner or Karlovic who do nothing all day but practice their serves? Name one.
I take Federer's serve without thinking twice and it's not even close.