Originally Posted by Prisoner of Birth
Top 5? Top 10? Top 15? Exact number would be nice but even a rough figure is fine.
I'd put him in my top 10, maybe around 7.
In the top ten. I don't include pre-Open era players....I have no base for evaluating Tilden, Pancho, etc. against modern players, so with that in mind, Andre would make the top ten...probably 7-10ish. I always forget someone when I do this, but quickly, it still goes something like this:
My list is a little iffy down in the second half, but it's "about" right, for the purpose of getting a number for AA.