Good thread, can't believe I missed it first time around.
I serve and volley a lot and I actually call foot faults on myself quite a bit, maybe once every couple of matches. It's pretty clear if I have done it and when I am coming in I have an unfair advantage by gaining the extra step.....I have never had a foot fault called against me I have only called it on myself.
Regarding calling it on others I suspect unless it was blatant I wouldn't notice it unless the opponent was also serve and volleying. If an advantage was being gained I would call it every time, just as I call it on myself. I would not expect it would be a problem against anyone I have played against.
If no advantage is being gained in a recreational match, well I probably wouldn't notice it or would simply let it go. In a league match I agree it is a tough call.
Very interesting to hear other folks take on this difficult situation we all face from time to time.
Head YT Prestige MP(2) iPrestige MP(3)iRadical MP(4)tiRadical MP(PT630)paintjob
MG Radical MP,PS 85(2) Max 200G(3)PDR + many more in hiding
Last edited by hrstrat57; 10-05-2012 at 07:09 PM.