Originally Posted by Zarfot Z
Nadal, by far. Much more consistent, less prone to shanking and a more solid shot overall.
Federer has the worst backhand in the top 4. It's obviously still a hellavashot, but there is no way it is better than Nadal's.
Who cares if it's a "solid shot" if he can't hit it down the line to save his life.
And that's just if you compare their drive backhands. Federer's slice
is lightyears ahead of Nadal's.
Not to mention, this isn't 2008. Federer is no longer leaking errors left and right from his BH.