View Single Post
Old 10-06-2012, 10:39 AM   #163
The Dark Knight
The Dark Knight's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 6,340

Originally Posted by VPhuc tennis fan View Post
Fed...avoid Nadal. Really? Back to the comparo that I asked. Where was Rafa when Fed won against Hewitt, Safin, and other supposedly weak players? Oh, I remember. Rafa skipped here, skipped there, injured here, injured there, still wore development diapers. Who was avoiding who?
He avoided having to play Rafa for one reason or another through no fault of his own.

But the facts are the facts . He simply has been dominated by Rafa and his 17 slams came mainly by not having to deal with Rafa for one reason or another.

If you just want to add up the slams and declare that Fed is the goat then you are absolutely right.

However for me it's a far more complicated issue than simply adding up the numbers in a robotic fashion.

I just cannot logically call someone the greatest player that ever lived when he keeps losing to someone . It just defys logic .
"Federer has to beat Nadal(if he wants) to be considered the greatest ever, certainly in my book." Pete Sampras
The Dark Knight is offline   Reply With Quote