[KenC]

Guys, I'm not talking about pros.

This concerns the masses here who typically play at the recreational and lower competitive levels. There are no Federers and Nadals here.

Since everyone here seems to be focused on what the pros do and not what typical players are capable of, maybe I could get to the same point by asking:
If you wanted to start playing competitive level tennis, would you rather model your style of play and strategy after Nadal or would you rather model your style and strategy after Federer?