Originally Posted by abmk
to answer the thread question :
nadal ~ djoker > murray on slow HC ...
murray ~ djoker >> nadal on fast HC ...
but I'd take fed at his best over any of them at their best on any HC ...
That's becoming hard to define on this forum, according to a number of people Fed's best tennis is lasting almost a decade now, which of course makes other members of the top 4 look like complete wussies in comparison as they can't even scrap together 3 years of being at their best combined
That said, presuming all 3 are at their best, I wouldn't favour Fed over Nadal or Novak on a slow outdoor HC, fast HC? Sure, let's say even a medium one (something like rebound ace) but on slow outdoor HC? Can't see it, I'd favour both of them over Fed in that scenario even at Fed's best to be honest.