Originally Posted by TMF
Yes, it's wrong to admire Federer but it's right to admire Rosewall.
I believe he's trying to write that it is wrong to admire Federer as the default choice for GOAT. And I do agree with him there. I don't think Federer is a slamdunk for GOAT but only one of the players who can be considered as a possibility.
Give BobbyOne this, he admires Rosewall but considers Laver every bit as good as Rosewall.
My opinion is that there are several players who are in consideration for GOAT status and I often change my mind depending on the information at hand.