Originally Posted by Timbo's hopeless slice
yes, either finish it at the weddng or go ahead and scourge the shire, don't just meander off into the west over interminable minutes...
GoT is a fine job, imho. Actually bringing the wonderful Tyrion Lannister to life is an amazing achievement in itself.
Although, I found Jackson's Faramir much more believable than the book's. In the book Faramir never once considered taking the Ring and using it, even though Gondor was failing. I'm glad Jackson gave him gave him some angst.