Originally Posted by Cindysphinx
Mmmm . . . that approach doesn't work all the time.
Say I hit a ball to you that bounces on your side of the court. You swing and shank it, and it barely grazes into a ceiling fixture directly above you.
That's my call to make, even though it happened on your side of the court.
Nothing works all the time....having said that, I read the question as a not-up situation. Rereading it, I have no idea what it refers to; it seems you could parse it several ways.