Originally Posted by Federer20042006
This is exactly why I don't think Federer is the GOAT. I realize a lot of that is Nadal, but it's not like Federer has decisively owned Djokovic since his emergence, and Murray used to own Federer until the supposed crippled Federer started to even it out over the past 3 years.
Please remember his career is spread over 3 eras. 99-03,04-08, 09-12. The players you are comparing are a full 5-6 years younger. This thread is meaningless without the context. It should be viewed that Fed has a decent record inspite of the age difference. GOAT does not mean he will have positive H2H till he dies.