In the examples you gave, I agree; that's going overboard. I get what you were trying to do, but my point was and is, if you're discussing strings, it's perfectly reasonable to bring up a string by a manufacturer that isn't represented here at TW. Not trying to convince you, however. It's just my opinion, and apparently it's one that's shared (at least in part) by the mods. I'm not sure what your rationale is with respect to why you feel it's not kosher, but that's cool. All I can say is it's a good thing you're not a mod lol.
Need help finding lost dog: walks with a limp, recently castrated, can only see out of one eye - answers to the name, "Lucky".