View Single Post
Old 11-20-2012, 07:25 AM   #642
BobbyOne
Legend
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Posts: 5,951
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dan Lobb View Post
No, but the pros looked for cheapest locales, that would mean indoor.
The Cannes was indoor.
Look at 1961. Here we have the Scandinavian Pro INDOOR. Is Scandinavia in Europe?
The "Milan Pro", with Gonzales and Cooper in the final. Sounds like indoor.
The Austrian Pro INDOOR, with Gonzales and MacKay in the final, MacKay beating Rosewall in the semifinal. Sounds like not clay.
The Inter-Country Pro Challenge in Turin, with the usual indoor guys coming through. Sounds like indoor.
Etc. etc.
We need some hard evidence to show that a clay venue was rented (these cost more to rent than a cold, claustrophobic gym or arena).
It still looks like 7 to 2 for Hoad over Rosewall on clay, in recognized major tournaments.
Dan, I accept some of your points. Generally in summer months in Continental Europe the surface was usually clay, not in winter months.

You again have omitted the 1958 4:1 clay balance of Rosewall against Hoad (Perrier Cup). This was not a minor event!

1959 Rome (GP) was maybe played on clay. Rosewall d Hoad 5-7,6-4,6-1

The same year in GP at Vienna Rosewall beat Hoad on clay 6-3,6-1.

In the same event, by the way, Rosewall beat Trabert 3-6,6-0,6-2, that meaning a strong revenge for Trabert's clear win at the French Pro...

Your 7:2 balance of Hoad vs. Rosewall is wrong!

Last edited by BobbyOne : 11-20-2012 at 09:34 AM.
BobbyOne is offline   Reply With Quote