View Single Post
Old 12-02-2012, 08:05 AM   #8
Talk Tennis Guru
TMF's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 20,670

Originally Posted by Mustard View Post
It proves that too many people are ignorant of tennis history. Federer is not a Phil Taylor or a Michael Phelps and the undisputed best without question. Tennis history is way too complex for that. I mean, come on, The Tennis Channel was putting Roy Emerson above Pancho Gonzales on their GOAT list. The only way they could have possibly come to that conclusion is by counting the number of mainstream majors, with 12 for Emerson and 2 for Gonzales. If you really know tennis history, you know how massively flawed that is.
Here is how the players are being evaluated...


* Number of Major Titles won
* Overall performance at Grand Slam Events
* Player Ranking
* Performance at ATP/WTA events
* Performance at Davis & Fed Cup events
* Records held or broken
* Intangibles(contribuition to tennis)
TMF is offline   Reply With Quote