Originally Posted by Sabratha
Maybe not Nadal, but I'm sure Djokovic would have a shot against Federer in 2005. He played well on faster courts, too. Look at the 2007 US Open final.
A shot yes, maybe even the favourite (goes for both Nadal and Novak) but dead certain to beat him (you stated it in your post like some fact)? No.
Then again, I'm hardly surprised to see you underrating Fed's play during his best years.