Originally Posted by TheFifthSet
Oh, overall I completely agree, Federer is a far better claycourter and will most likely end up with better credentials on clay.
However, at Djokovic's peak, I think his performance against the field on clay would be better than Fed at his peak, if they were both playing at their peaks at the same time. Remember that how they match up with Nadal is a huge, HUGE part of it, because if they wanna win titles on clay they'll have to go through Nadal so that's a massive piece of the pie.
Erm fed vs djoker is 3-3 on clay and one of those wins for fed was a RETIREMENT. Are you kidding me djoker is the only one can even come close to challenge Nadal on clay.