Originally Posted by NadalAgassi
Women- Serena wins on all but clay. On clay Graf or Seles wins (I think Evert is the greatest clay courter ever, but she would not win in an all peak playing match).
Men- On grass Sampras wins, on fast hard courts Laver wins (he didnt get to play much on it, but with his overall game he would be near unbeatable that type of court on a peak day), on carpet Becker or Sampras wins, on rebound ace Djokovic wins, on clay Nadal wins.
I don't know if that's true (the words I put in bold) but I like the thought behind it. I think you could be right as far as Evert is concerned. Serena isn't exactly bad on clay however so I wouldn't necessarily rule her out.
I may put Henin there for clay also.