Originally Posted by cc0509
You have to be kidding me. Nobody cares about surface GOAT, it is overall GOAT that matters. And there is a debate amongst some people with respect to clay goat, some still think there is a debate between Nadal and Borg. I personally think Nadal has slightly surpassed Borg now, but it is close.
For overall GOAT, I don't believe in the GOAT concept but Federer is the closest to that moniker for sure and no, there really is no debate at this point.
It's not just about overall achievements(titles won) but the style of play which is a genius never before seen. Fed has the full array of shots.