Originally Posted by Rjtennis
Serena would beat Mac purely based on movement and fitness. I'm also not sure that the seniors tour isn't somewhat rigged. Mac doesn't move that well and some of the younger guys should crush him. I'm still amazed at how well he plays but I dont think he is any better than a 5.5 player. There are a lot of D1 players who would easily handle him.
5.5?? - That's pretty silly!!!!
lot of D1 players?? - Depends if you think 10 or 20 is a lot.
Yes, the guys playing Challengers would beat him (as they did Muster almost all the time). Mac would beat the guys playing Futures now.
Mac would have a significant advantage in movement over Serena.
Originally Posted by helloworld
Andre would beat Serena 6-0 6-0, and McEnroe was even better than Andre that day.
Yes, Andre would often beat Serena 6-0, 6-0 if he went full-out. However, it is difficult to tell just how hard Agassi was playing against McEnroe.