Yeah, you would think it would be closer to the water, but maybe that's how they can provide such good food at reasonable prices: lower overhead.
We also ate at a place on 5th Ave called 'Citrus'. The food was excellent, but for the price we paid, you would expect that. The atmosphere was nicer, though, as we ate outside & 'people watched'.
Capt Marcos was a dive on the outside (the photo on the website is a flattering one), but again, the food & service was excellent.
"Nobody beats Vitas Gerulaitis 17 times in a row" -- Vitas Gerulaitis, after beating Jimmy Connors on his 17th try.