I voted for Federer. It was obvious that he was going to win given the nature of this forum. We might get some more balanced voting if this thread were in the Former Pro Player section. Most of the voting wouldn't be any less biased, but Fed wouldn't be winning by such a ridiculous amount.
To be honest the poll's results don't surprise me. It's fairly clear how this forum stands on Federer.
Incidentally, the topic of this thread if fleshed out fully would render obsolete most of the threads in General Pro Player discussion and a good chunk of the ones in Match Results and the Former Pro Player section. Wouldn't it be fun to have only one Goat debate thread?