View Single Post
Old 01-10-2013, 06:15 AM   #111
Join Date: Jul 2012
Posts: 7,773

Originally Posted by krosero View Post
They might be, but only if achievements are separated entirely from playing strength. In practice we rarely do that; and we wouldn't want to. Nobody considers Emerson's 12 amateur Slams to be of the value of Laver's 11.

Ultimately the two -- achievements and playing level -- are bound up together. Playing to a high level is ultimately an achievement, and one which all of us want to see in any of our choices for GOAT (or other similar honorifics, like best player of the 1980s, or claycourt GOAT, etc.), or when asking which of two players is the greater one.
krosero, I agree.
BobbyOne is offline   Reply With Quote