Originally Posted by nikdom
Doesn't matter IMO. We can disagree.
I'm not disagreeing. I'm just saying how can we possibly ever know.
You can say Federer has 17 slams and all these records and sublime skills but I've also seen Murray legitimately bagel Nadal for the loss of only 4 points in the set and Nadal said Murray was completely unplayable.
What I'm saying is would Federer's A game stand up to that.
Truth is we don't really know.