Originally Posted by tudwell
He has the same number of titles as Federer, but Federer - due in part mostly to his greater age and therefore longer career - has more consistency. Djokovic has four titles and his next best result is two quarterfinals. Federer's been in, what, like 10 straight semifinals? Along with a runner-up. I'm sure Djokovic will overtake Federer and Agassi by winning a fifth title, but at the moment, I don't think there's a clear choice between the three.
Sure, you can still make an argument for any of the 3.
However, Novak won 3 in a row which for me personally puts him at #1 regarding AO.