Originally Posted by octogon
Murray. If Nadal were still in the mix, I doubt he'd have a slam right now.
Either Nadal would beat him in the US open semi-final, or Murray would beat Nadal, but kill himself in the process, leaving him easy meat for Djokovic in the final. Or he'd face Nadal in the final and choke.
Yep - that's definitely what would happen. Or maybe Nadal would lose to Rosol?
I guess we'll never know with any certainty what would
The only facts we have to go on are that Murray hasn't choked in the last 4 big finals he's played in and that Nadal and Murray are 2:2 in hardcourt slams.