Seems like Henin had a tougher field, no?
Originally Posted by Jack Romeo
obviously, you're asking about prime seles here, right? well, i think it would depend a bit on how henin is serving. there were matches where she got outhit by the likes of sharapova and pierce because she didn't serve well. seles is just as aggressive with the return as those players so she can take control in that kind of situation. but overall, henin would match up well against seles. she is a great athlete, is mentally tough, has her own power, can counter against power, and can play from any position on the court. remember that past-prime navratilova had a respectable record against pre-prime to prime seles. so i would even give henin the edge.
If Henin > Seles, and IF Seles>=Graf (arguable)... would we apply transitivity here?