Originally Posted by The-Champ
Utter BS. Any Federer of 2006 on clay would destroy that Federer of 2011 plus Rafa in the final. 2006 Federer on clay would have beaten 2010 Nadal on clay too, convincingly. I say that as a Nadal fan...
So you'd say 2006/2007 Clay Federer was fantastic clay tennis and if it weren't for Rafa's clay ceiling GOATness that he (Federer) was turning in performances that were absolutely noteworthy historically?
Also it sounds like you're saying that 2006/7/8 Nadal on clay would wipe 2010/11/12 Nadal off the dirt?