Based on women I have met or seen.
My mother said Federer was nice looking. Liked Haas and Agassi the most. Never said anything good about Safin. referred to Baghdatis as not bad looking. From my information, she thought Haas was the hottest. Was watching some Haas vs. Agassi tape, and she asks me who he (Haas) was. LOL
Other comments I recall.
Random girl: Liked Ginepri and JC Ferrero
Newscaster: Liked Sampras and Rafter.