Originally Posted by Nadalgaenger
There is so much Nadal hate on here it isn't funny.
Why is it so hard for people to recognize him as an all-time great. He currently cannot be called GOAT, but if he can come back and win another 4 or so majors then the conversation has to be started again.
A lot of people recognize him as an all time great, some as THE clay all-time great (the other think he might be tied with Borg). He is without a doubt in the top 10 of all time. But your thread is not about him being a great player, it is about him being better than is rival because he has a winning H2H against, AND was clever enough to lose against more different players than them. You can't really hope an interesting discussion with these kind of premise. Just like the other thread with Fed being fun while Nole is boring has few chance that Nole's fan will acknowledge that Fed's game is beautiful.