Originally Posted by Surecatch
Any idea of what I can expect for a recovery and getting back to playing time given it's my "off" shoulder?
Depends, since it's your non-playing shoulder, expectations should be low in your recovery (not saying you can't go nuts and rehab it to be as good as before).
To give you an idea on the range of functionality of the rotator cuff: most people have torn (partial - complete) rotator cuffs. But because their demands for it is lower than a tennis player/baseball player/other athletes, they don't notice it because they never push it enough for it to be symptomatic.