Thread: Clay Court GOAT
View Single Post
Old 03-19-2013, 08:37 AM   #1226
Phoenix1983
Hall Of Fame
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 2,557
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Flash O'Groove View Post

Can someone explain me the coherence of ranking these to guys so far from each others, when one win everything and the other was runner-up of everything?
Hoodjem ranked Federer at #19 all-time, I don't think that's unreasonable. Certainly I don't think he can be in the top ten all-time when you have the likes of, chronologically,

- Wilding
- Cochet
- Rosewall
- Pietrangeli
- Santana
- Gimeno
- Borg
- Vilas
- Lendl
- Wilander
- Muster
- Kuerten

and some others who I've likely forgotten.

Top 20 all-time on clay is about right for Fed. He would have won more were it not for Nadal, but having said that, he wouldn't have run riot - past clay greats like Kuerten (as he showed in the FO 2004), Lendl and Wilander would still probably have beaten him, at least some of the time.
__________________
Sloane Stephens and Laura Robson: future WTA world No 1 and 2.
Phoenix1983 is offline   Reply With Quote