Originally Posted by BobbyOne
NatF, Thanks for this serious post.
Bud once said to me (on the phone) that Rosewall might be the GOAT by two reasons: his longevity and his two wins against Laver at Dallas.
Longevity should not be a reason for someone to be considered GOAT.
Rosewall's longevity was so great that he managed to play in five Wimbledon finals - yet could win none...