Originally Posted by J_R_B
He should have answered the questions honestly and if that made him a 4.5, then he should appeal that down. In this section, since he actually was a 4.0 in his last valid computer rating, he would have been granted the appeal for sure. By faking the self-rating so you don't have to go through the appeals is stupid and just open yourself up to this type of grievance.
If he lied on the self-rate then he can, and should, be punished for doing so. The self-rate questionnaire has two places where players must check and acknowledge that they are telling the truth and not omitting any pertinent information.