Originally Posted by goran_ace
Are you paying him to play on your team? Sounds more like the other captain doesn't want you to have a college player on your roster. There's no NCAA/ITA rule that would prohibit it but if the player is in-season he may not be allowed to play due to a team or department policy e.g. a lot of teams don't let players participate in intramurals because risk of injury.
I played DIII soccer and we had some rules from our coach.....but NCAA rules do not prohibit play, even during a season. WE played in local indoor soccer leagues during our season all the time.....but maybe that is different since it was not sanctioned as strictly as USTA play. Maybe the vagueness of the DIII rule listed above was why this was not an issue for us.