Originally Posted by McEnroeisanartist
If Federer stays on 17 Grand Slams and Nadal ends up with 18 Grand Slams say 2 Australian Opens, 10 French Opens, 3 Wimbledons, and 3 U.S. Opens and 0 ATP Tour Finals (this doesn't sound that far fetched), would Nadal be considered GOAT when Federer would have 2 more Australian Opens, 9 less French Opens, 4 more Wimbledons, 2 more U.S. Opens, and 6 more ATP Tour Finals.
Yes. It's all and only about the slam total.
Pete said so.
Step 1: Refute content of argument. If that fails, Step 2: question intelligence of the author. If that fails, Step 3: demonize the messenger.