Originally Posted by McEnroeisanartist
If Federer stays on 17 Grand Slams and Nadal ends up with 18 Grand Slams say 2 Australian Opens, 10 French Opens, 3 Wimbledons, and 3 U.S. Opens and 0 ATP Tour Finals (this doesn't sound that far fetched), would Nadal be considered GOAT when Federer would have 2 more Australian Opens, 9 less French Opens, 4 more Wimbledons, 2 more U.S. Opens, and 6 more ATP Tour Finals.
Yes. It's all and only about the slam total.
Pete said so.
The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure, while the intelligent are full of doubt.