Clay Court GOAT

[BobbyOne]

Originally Posted by Phoenix1983

Yes, we agree on many issues, just not the rankings of Federer and Rosewall...

Phoenix, Thanks for your nice word. I need such words in these times...

I can live with our discrepancy. It would be fine if you could rank Muscles still at third place...

[Feather]

Originally Posted by BobbyOne

Federer fanatic: In the 1940s to 1960s a certain Pancho Segura came from Ecuador. A big country?

I am NOT a Federer fanatic. Except for you, no one has called me a fanatic. I like Roger Federer but I like so many players. I have never said that Roger is a GOAT as I believe that it's an insult to all the legends of the game who played in different conditions.

The difference is, almost everyone calls you Federer hater..

Anyway, you are free to call me whatever you like

[BobbyOne]

Originally Posted by Feather

I am NOT a Federer fanatic. Except for you, no one has called me a fanatic. I like Roger Federer but I like so many players. I have never said that Roger is a GOAT as I believe that it's an insult to all the legends of the game who played in different conditions.

The difference is, almost everyone calls you Federer hater..

Anyway, you are free to call me whatever you like

Okay, you are not a Federer fanatic. Then tell me why you and others insult me every time when I critisize a Federer weakness.

If almost everyone would call me a Federer hater, I would stop to write here. Fortunately there still are some fair posters even though the Federer admirers have already droven away that true gentleman pc1. Note: I mention him NOT only because he has defended me several times against unfair attacs.

[Feather]

Originally Posted by BobbyOne

Okay, you are not a Federer fanatic. Then tell me why you and others insult me every time when I critisize a Federer weakness.

If almost everyone would call me a Federer hater, I would stop to write here. Fortunately there still are some fair posters even though the Federer admirers have already droven away that true gentleman pc1. Note: I mention him NOT only because he has defended me several times against unfair attacs.

Show me one post of mine where I insulted you? just one post. I have never resorted to name calling. I have said that you are biased. That's not an insult. You show bias, so I pointed that

[abmk]

Originally Posted by BobbyOne

Okay, you are not a Federer fanatic. Then tell me why you and others insult me every time when I critisize a Federer weakness.

If almost everyone would call me a Federer hater, I would stop to write here. Fortunately there still are some fair posters even though the Federer admirers have already droven away that true gentleman pc1. Note: I mention him NOT only because he has defended me several times against unfair attacs.

its because you point out non-existent weaknesses ( like lack of touch ) and exaggerate his "weaknesses"

I myself have said federer can be defensive with his BH/returning , his volleys can be sloppy at times and that he can be stubborn with his strategy at times ....

but if you say he can't volley or his BH doesn't work vs any top player (in a baseline-dominated era ) and can't change strategies at all ( when he's done that many times ) ...... reasonable people who've seen much much more of federer than you have are bound to criticize you ...(krosero himself has very politely pointed out the tons of flaws in your arguments)

[BobbyOne]

Originally Posted by abmk

its because you point out non-existent weaknesses ( like lack of touch ) and exaggerate his "weaknesses"

I myself have said federer can be defensive with his BH/returning , his volleys can be sloppy at times and that he can be stubborn with his strategy at times ....

but if you say he can't volley or his BH doesn't work vs any top player (in a baseline-dominated era ) and can't change strategies at all ( when he's done that many times ) ...... reasonable people who've seen much much more of federer than you have are bound to criticize you ...(krosero himself has very politely pointed out the tons of flaws in your arguments)

Aggressive abmk, When did I say that Federer can't volley?????????????