The above post belongs in the TALL TALE section.
Yeah, it was pretty sad.
I'd watch this guy hit against a former A level player, now 73, for two years, and knew he was above my level, so while I watched, I never asked him to hit.
Then he asks me, like in July. We never got together, timing at all, but on Friday we scheduled a hit.
Hitting wasn't too bad, although he had a depth and power advantage. I never said I was anything more than a low 4.0, so he had lots of room to play 4.0 above me.
Sets were different. He had a powerful second serve (one DF total in 3 sets), and handcuffed me repeatedly going into my body. His wide serves were normal. The angles he created on anything short of the baseline was beyond my reach, him knowing I lack speed, and him hitting within 3' of the sidelines, usually with topspin, so I had little time to make it over to the ball and recover after my desperate returns.
I could win a few points S/V to his backhand, but more often than not, his low return of serve got him another chance, and he lobbed smartly to mid NML most of the time. I can hit overheads, but putting away a overheads from mid NML is not so easy.
My twist to his forehand on ad court worked pretty well, but I don't own that serve, and anything short gives him a low bounce, which he can pummel with his forehand. I was maybe 50/50 there.
My first serve was off, I hadn't played in 10 days, going to WineCountry, SF, Yosemite/Tahoe for 9 days. The few I got in worked just fine, but in 3 sets, maybe 4 flat serves total, missing easily 20 each set.
His backhand was stronger and more consistent than his forehand, so he neutralized the lefty advantage.
Once again, my second serve decided to abandon me. Possibly as many as 4 games would not have been lost outright if I hadn't DF'd, and twice that number more if I'd get decent depth with wider placements. But I didn't.
Maybe you guys are right, I"m closer to 3.5 than 4.0. However, that would mean my normal crew of 4.0's are also 3.5's, which would make all the old 3-3.5's look like beginners. Monday, my first day back, everyone was lazy and we played tiebreak singles. I was 50/50 with 3 different peers.