chimneysweep
Semi-Pro
I am fine with those who rate Navratilova higher than Evert. I think it might be correct. However what I dont like is people seem to have Navratilova far above. I think they should be seen as relatively equal.
Yes Martina is superior in peak level play and also dominance. However Evert is superior in consistency and surface versatility. Navratilova might seem to have more longevity, but Evert has greater longevity of near peak level play. It should be considered a virtual toss up to which is higher, and not Martina clearly ahead. And they are the easiest to compare as they are contemporaries, while comparing both to Serena or Graf or Corut is more subjective, so I can accept a lot of differing options.
Yes Martina is superior in peak level play and also dominance. However Evert is superior in consistency and surface versatility. Navratilova might seem to have more longevity, but Evert has greater longevity of near peak level play. It should be considered a virtual toss up to which is higher, and not Martina clearly ahead. And they are the easiest to compare as they are contemporaries, while comparing both to Serena or Graf or Corut is more subjective, so I can accept a lot of differing options.