Some additonal thoughts...
- I guess there's one more aspect I'd like to mention, which is, in my opinion, the hardest jump is from the 3.0/3.5 levels up to 4.0 and beyond. There's two ways of looking at NTRP generally, one of which is "I'm now playing in a 4.0 league" or "my strokes and strategies are 4.0 level" and they are not the same thing for a couple of reasons: (1) There used to be a 5.5 level in leagues and tournaments, but the number of NTRP events was getting to be too much for tournament directors, so 5.5 went away. What happened to all the then 5.5s? They became 5.0s, so there was a kind of downward creep. 4.0 is now a pretty difficult level, with a lot of 4.5 type strokes and strategies in evidence. (2) Having said all that good stuff, what you see, up to about the 4.0 level, is a lot of people with iffy strokes and strategies who play lots of events and compete well.
If you look at the descriptions of the 3.5 through 4.5 levels, which I quoted above, in terms of stroke production and strategy, it seems to be implying that there is a continuum from 3.5 upward. That is, a 3.5 has a pretty solid forehand, for example, just not the same pace, variety, placement that a 4.0/4.5 has...but that'll come with time and practice.
In reality, nothing could be further from the truth. A lot of 3.0/3.5s arrive at that level just by playing a lot and getting a lot of match time...but their strokes and strategies are basically junk. That doesn't mean they are bad people, just that they never got any help getting started playing the game. I'm not making this up. When I watch a 3.0/3.5 level match...doesn't matter if it's men or women, single or doubles...I inevitably see the following problems, and these problems are holding these players back from going any higher:
- Serving with a Western forehand grip, basically arming the ball, no leg drive, no rotational momentum from the upper body, little or no snap at the top, generally erratic toss.
- Inconsistent return of serve, usually by taking a huge backswing and big swipe at the ball. Poor court positioning for the serve; poor reading of the direction/spin/pace of the serve.
- Push backhand, arming the ball, not using the legs or torso, stepping back.
- Wild swings at the forehand, occasional winners, many errors, a different forehand on every point.
- Wild swings on the volley...you get the joke.
- No overhead...but a very good lob (probably better than mine!).
So what's my point? Basically, for most people, trying to get above the 3.5 level by trying harder is basically the definition of insanity...doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. To get above these levels, it usually takes completely changing your game...new strokes, new strategy, new physical preparation, new movement on the court, new ways of competing to win.
Actually, this happens at all levels, but I think it's most prevalent trying to improve above 3.5. To give you a personal example (ahem)...I am now 58. I played high school team tennis, and tournament tennis all through college. In my late 20s/early 30s, I was playing the Colorado circuit, which then had no NTRP...it was just Men's Tennis, singles and doubles. My best year, I won a tournament in Breckenridge, and got to the last 16 in singles and last 8 in doubles at the Intermountain Championships. Then I got burned out on tennis and got into road bike racing. In my mid forties, I got back on a tennis court again...but didn't play any tournaments for the first 5 years back, just hit lots of balls and got used to the new equipment. In 2002, I was looking for a way to get back into tournaments again, but I knew my game wasn't quite there. I got some coaching from Dave Hodge, then Colorado University Men's Assistant Coach and former ATP player. Remember, I had already played tennis for a lot of years, and won tournaments. I though I had a pretty fair game...but just by hitting with me, Dave was able to show me otherwise. I had a great flat first serve...but no percentages, and no variety. Some days, I blew people off the court, other days, I couldn't get 20% of my first serves in. My second serve was a joke...a lot of mustard, but many double faults. I had a Continenal forehand...not always a bad thing, but mine was. A great wristy backand...which some days went in, others didn't. A great volley game...some days, other days, because I was taking too much swing, I couldn't hit a fat bull in the behind with a shovel. A great return...some days, others not.
So how did I win all those matches before? Perserverance, sweat, and sheer luck. I won when I was in the zone, which wasn't very often, lost to my grandmother the rest of the time. So for the first two years with Dave, we worked on strategy and movement, but basically we worked on having me unlearn all this stuff that was getting in my way, and coming up with some solid strokes that I could put some zip on and still expect to fall in the court more than every other Wednesday.
Dave moved on to Stanford, and for the next year I trained with CU Men's Assistant Chris Garner, former ATP player who beat Todd Martin (twice) and Evgeny Kafelnikov, among others, and once reached the last 16 at the Australian Open. Based on that resume, he should have had me trying stuff like Federer pulls off, right? Nope, more of the same...move your feet, early prep, consistent swing patterns, consistent smart tactics.
Chris moved on to Ohio State, so for the next year...last summer...I trained with CU Head Men's Coach Sam Winterbotham. Much, much more of the same...and then after about a month, when my strokes and movement were solid enough, we moved full tilt to playing points, working on my game..."don't always try to hit the other guy off the court!...you have talent and variety, use it! Use the court, make the other guy work harder, play smarter, not harder" is essentially what he taught me. Four years to get to that point, but that was fine because the work and effort, the journey, turned out to be much more important than the goal. And my goal, instead of "get back into tournaments" became "get back into tennis, have fun, challenge yourself, and Aim High, because there's no ball you can't hit, and no match you can't win." I'm still working on that last one, but everything else is happening, in spades...